semi colons and lists

Started by indar9, January 16, 2019, 10:53:24 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

indar9

Must a series or listing of things in a sentence always be preceded by a statement followed by a colon and then the listed items be separated by semi-colons and what about the final item that is preceded by a conjunction?

He took his toys to the sandbox: a shovel; a bucket; sifter(,?) and his little rake.

or can lists just be separated by semi colons?

he took his shovel; bucket; sifter and his little rake

hillwalker3000

Most would advise against the (mis)use of semi-colons. They are hardly ever used nowadays, and certainly not in the context you suggest.
Commas would be the accepted punctuation.
QuoteHe took his toys to the sandbox: a shovel, a bucket, sifter and his little rake.
It's not a great sentence, however, because the list refers back to the toys not the sandbox.
Compare with 'He took out his toys: a shovel, a bucket, a sifter and a rake.'

Similarly
QuoteHe took his shovel, bucket, sifter and his little rake.

There's no need for a comma after 'sifter' (called an Oxford comma by some which used to be considered the norm).

It would be different if you had written 'He took out his favourite toys, a sub-machine gun and a cleaver' which could suggest his favourite toys are a sub-machine gun and cleaver.
To make it clearer this is indeed the case, you would need to use a colon: 'He took out his favourite toys: a sub-machine gun, and a cleaver.'

compared with 'He took out his favourite toys, a sub-machine gun, and a cleaver' which clearly implies he took out three or more separate items.

H3K

indar9

WOW! Thanks HW. I tried to read up on this and came to the conclusion that the Oxford comma was preferred. Who gave THAT advice? Now Im going to have to go over my manuscript (for the umpteeth time) and change back to commas which I had in the first place.