Past and Present Tense

Started by AssetMB, May 18, 2018, 08:53:27 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

AssetMB

I tried researching this a variety of places but I saw conflicting advice, and now I've run around in too many circles and become dizzy. I'm feeling a little lost. Can someone explain to me the rules of past and present tense?

Obviously there are exceptions to every rule. In general, I've heard that you pick a tense and stick with it, but when is it considering mixing? For example:
"Black smoke spat at the ceiling and she twisted her wrist slowly, watching the numbers – and her glaring mathematical mistakes – disappear. "

This is (supposed to be) mainly past tense, but technically switches to present when she's 'watching the numbers'. I saw some writers explain it's a more acceptable shift because it creates a sense of time - the smoke has already moved but at the second you read it, her focus on watching is happening currently. I've also seen writers who cried out at any and all mixing (except in specific situations like a flashback). I have looked quickly through a few published books but for every similar example I can find, I can not quite grasp if this is something that is considered a 'common mistake' or an inadvisable way of writing, or if I am just thinking about it too hard.

So what is your take on it, and was the example sentence something that could be accepted?

hillwalker3000

Quote"Black smoke spat at the ceiling and she twisted her wrist slowly, watching the numbers – and her glaring mathematical mistakes – disappear. "

It looks a bit of a mess, but that's because it's structured rather oddly. The em dashes don't help.
There is no verb in the present tense in this sentence.
What the writer presumably meant is:
'. . .she twisted her wrist, watching the numbers and her mistakes disappear'
rather than
'. . .she twisted her wrist, watching the numbers - and as she does this her mistakes disappear'.
The gerund 'watching' is not technically in present tense because there is no verb accompanying it - compare 'is watching' (present tense) with 'was watching' (past tense). It's implicit that she twisted her wrist as she was watching rather than as she is watching (which would make no sense).

H3K

Jo Bannister


There's nothing wrong or even unusual about this sentence.  It isn't switching tenses at all: it's entirely in the past tense.  Hilly's better than me at putting names to the different bits, but what you have done is add a clause (watching the numbers disappear) with a secondary introduction (- and her glaring mathematical mistakes -) inside it.  You haven't changed tenses, nor should you have done.

If you read it without the bit between the dashes, I think you'll see there's no problem.


AssetMB

Alright. I think it was a case of thinking about it too hard. I guess I saw the 'ing' and just considered it switching but I can see it's not the case, and depends more on what comes previously. I believe I have a slightly better grasp now. Thank you!

(And I'm getting the hint! No more em dashes!)

Jo Bannister

Don't give up dashes entirely - they have a job to do too! 

But taking out everything that's detachable helps you to analyse your sentence.  It's like "he and I", which is correct as the subject of sentence but not as the object.  "Martin and I went shopping" - fine.  "The assistant approached Martin and I" - wrong.  Take Martin away and you can see that it's wrong. 

Gyppo

Take out the detachables.  I wish someone had explained it that way when I  was at school.  Maybe they did, but I was too busy looking out of the window and dreaming up stories or scribbling them down ;-)

ST

Rules.

There is no real way not to be effected by them. We are told this and that throughout our learning growth - so they are grated into the mix.

The thing is, for writing prose, there is no need to see them. Basically, it is the story which becomes the rule. If a writer tells the story it can't have a word in capital letters in the middle of text, well then the writer is interfering with the story. Never a good thing.

There are many excellent examples of this art, in published works.

I believe there is a term for when a writer uses both tenses in the same story/sentence. The name escapes me.  I was never one to memorize names and definitions. It's easier to just understand their principle and use them as the story sees fit.

Define your search around the net, in regards to past and present - future. Make sure you understand it before changing your writing. 

The danger in learning more and more about writing is that sometimes your writing gets over-written by the rules you're trying to  understand. Step back. Be the writer again.

I went on and on. Probably you didn't get a thing from this.

Keep at it. Don't hesitate to ask questions. It's how writing evolves.

ST

AssetMB

That is definitely a helpful way of explaining it! Jo, can you explain a little more how you tell it is detachable? In your example, I remember quite often being taught that "The assistant approached Martin and I" was not only correct, but the recommended way to write that sentence. Yet what you say makes more sense to me, and I can definitely hear the difference when Martin is removed.

As for the rules of writing, there seems to be a very delicate balance. I don't want to get embroiled in technicalities or anything, but I also do not want to discover later on that I've made a mistake I need to go through an entire manuscript to fix (like my old capital letter dialog tags!) I think in this case I was more uncomfortable with my inability to explain why I personally thought it was one way or another that made me seek out help here. It's one thing if I just turn out to be wrong, but another if I didn't know in the first place and just guessed, when there are plenty of more knowledgeable people here to ask (if I cannot figure it out myself).

hillwalker3000

Quote from: AssetMB on May 24, 2018, 05:28:08 PM
I remember quite often being taught that "The assistant approached Martin and I" was not only correct, but the recommended way to write that sentence.

Trust me - it's not!

The only correct version using 'Martin and I' would be 'Martin and I were approached by the assistant'. You can split this to say 'Martin was approached by the assistant' and 'I was approached by the assistant'.
In your example, if you split it the same way as your teacher suggests, you'd have 'The assistant approached Martin' and 'The assistant approached I' which is complete nonsense.

H3K

Jo Bannister

What Hilly says. 

If you're not sure, try reducing the sentence to its simplest components.  "I approached the assistant" but "The assistant approached me".  "I" is the subject of the first sentence, "me" is the object of the second.

But I can't say it often enough: if you're struggling to see which is appropriate, you're not reading enough.  You don't need to be taught this stuff, you just need to see it done correctly often enough that it becomes second nature.

Gyppo

But you can deliberately use 'I' the wrong way to create a rural impression/effect in dialogue.  But that won't work if you also use it incorrectly in the main body of the text.

"The farmer approached I, waving his shotgun and looking mad as hell."

This is an example of deliberately breaking the general rules for a specific effect.  But use it sparingly.  Do it too often and you'll just annoy your readers.

graphophobia

Jo's explanation is the one I've always heard, if unsure about I or me, remove the other party from the sentence to check that it makes sense. My husband and I went to the shop (I went to the shop) as opposed to My husband and me went to the shop (Me went to the shop).